Jan. 19, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
If a thief appeared to be taunting his victims, it worked.
Two stolen televisions and a missing dog triggered a New Year’s Day fight in Hillsville.
Pennsylvania State Police said Amanda Marie Berresford, 23, of Oakdale Road, Darlington, and Mark David Gates, 30, of West Main Street, Hillsville, went to a neighbor’s house on Churchill Road looking for the man they claimed was responsible.
Instead of finding the culprit, Berresford and Gates ended up each being charged with eight offenses that include burglary, simple assault and harassment.
Gates told police that a year before, someone had entered his house and left with a JVC television. The person reportedly struck once more.
When they returned from a 2011 New Year’s party at a local club, Berresford noticed instructions for the old TV taped to a door. Gates then discovered the replacement TV gone and his dog had disappeared.
Police said Berresford then went into Christopher David List’s home during the early hours of Jan. 1. He told her the man she and Gates were looking for had left 15 minutes earlier.
“I told her I had no idea where (the man) went, or about a TV,” List told police.
Berresford left and then came back with Gates. Court paperwork said the quarrel escalated into a fight among Berresford, Gates, List and Mathew Robert Bohn, who also lives at List’s home. An unidentified woman and two children were in the house when the altercation took place.
Both groups claimed the other started the fight.
A fifth person, Thomas Franklin Weatherly, had been upstairs sleeping when the commotion began. Weatherly said he heard threats involving List being killed. He came downstairs with an unloaded rifle, police said.
“I got a gun, get out,” he reportedly yelled.
Police said Berresford knocked the weapon from Weatherly, and she began to choke him. Berresford and Gates fled after Weatherly warned again he would use the gun.
Police noted Weatherly was the only sober person among the five participants.
The preliminary hearings for Berresford and Gates are scheduled for 9:30 a.m. Tuesday in Lawrence County Central Court.
Saturday, January 29, 2011
Ellwood 'pack rat' sentenced in firearms case
Jan. 14, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A judge rejected an argument that an Ellwood City felon’s “unique history” as a pack rat should result in probation.
Yesterday, Senior U.S. District Judge Maurice B. Cohill sentenced Dean Huzinec to four years in prison for violating federal firearms and explosives laws.
Huzinec pleaded guilty June 30, 2010, to possessing a firearm by a convicted felon and possession of an explosive.
U.S. Attorney David J. Hickton’s office announced the penalty against the 49-year-old Huzinec.
According to court records, the Fire Street resident possessed 19 firearms, a firearm silencer and explosive material on Aug. 17, 2008.
Calling her client a tinkerer, attorney Linda E. J. Cohn said Huzinec “collects anything that he can fix up and re-sell or re-use himself.”
“Although he should not possess firearms, he is far from being a person who stockpiles weapons or possesses them for any sinister purpose,” she wrote in her sentencing report.
Cohn, an assistant federal public defender, said Huzinec knew he shouldn’t have had the weapons.
“Several of the firearms in this case were registered to his ex-girlfriend,” she continued. “Other firearms were old guns that had belonged to his father, and a couple of them were at his house because he was trying to fix them for other people.
“Mr. Huzinec freely admits that he bought a number of the firearms at flea markets.”
Assistant U.S. Attorney Craig W. Haller wrote in his response Huzinec knew his collection of weapons violated the law.
“The need for deterrence is quite apparent in light of Mr. Huzinec’s decision to pursue his interest in firearms and explosive material instead of demonstrating respect for the laws — laws Mr. Huzinec was very familiar with,” Haller said. “To Mr. Huzinec’s credit, he acknowledged his responsibility for his collection of guns and explosive material readily and repeatedly after he was arrested.”
The investigation included the following departments: the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; the Franklin Township Police Department; the Allegheny County Police Department Bomb Squad; the Beaver County District Attorney's Office; the Pennsylvania State Police; and the Ellwood City police.
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A judge rejected an argument that an Ellwood City felon’s “unique history” as a pack rat should result in probation.
Yesterday, Senior U.S. District Judge Maurice B. Cohill sentenced Dean Huzinec to four years in prison for violating federal firearms and explosives laws.
Huzinec pleaded guilty June 30, 2010, to possessing a firearm by a convicted felon and possession of an explosive.
U.S. Attorney David J. Hickton’s office announced the penalty against the 49-year-old Huzinec.
According to court records, the Fire Street resident possessed 19 firearms, a firearm silencer and explosive material on Aug. 17, 2008.
Calling her client a tinkerer, attorney Linda E. J. Cohn said Huzinec “collects anything that he can fix up and re-sell or re-use himself.”
“Although he should not possess firearms, he is far from being a person who stockpiles weapons or possesses them for any sinister purpose,” she wrote in her sentencing report.
Cohn, an assistant federal public defender, said Huzinec knew he shouldn’t have had the weapons.
“Several of the firearms in this case were registered to his ex-girlfriend,” she continued. “Other firearms were old guns that had belonged to his father, and a couple of them were at his house because he was trying to fix them for other people.
“Mr. Huzinec freely admits that he bought a number of the firearms at flea markets.”
Assistant U.S. Attorney Craig W. Haller wrote in his response Huzinec knew his collection of weapons violated the law.
“The need for deterrence is quite apparent in light of Mr. Huzinec’s decision to pursue his interest in firearms and explosive material instead of demonstrating respect for the laws — laws Mr. Huzinec was very familiar with,” Haller said. “To Mr. Huzinec’s credit, he acknowledged his responsibility for his collection of guns and explosive material readily and repeatedly after he was arrested.”
The investigation included the following departments: the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; the Franklin Township Police Department; the Allegheny County Police Department Bomb Squad; the Beaver County District Attorney's Office; the Pennsylvania State Police; and the Ellwood City police.
District’s consultant fees drop
Jan. 13, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A revised proposal will trim $2,000 in consultant fees that the New Castle Area School District has to pay.
During its regular session last night, the school board voted 6-3 to hire John M. Pappas of Eckles Construction Services. Pappas will advise the district in the selection of a construction manager to oversee a $19 million renovation and creation of an early learning center at the site of the Harry W. Lockley Kindergarten Center.
The district originally negotiated a $6,500 contract. Pappas would have reviewed 16 of the 18 proposals submitted.
When the board agreed to reject bids exceeding $500,000, that left seven companies to consider. Board member Brad Olson proposed that Pappas lower his fee.
“I just renegotiated with a smaller scope of work,” business manager Joseph Ambrosini said. “He didn’t need to put in the time for those over $500,000.”
Pappas reduced his the cost of his services to $4,500.
Board members J. Allan Joseph, Karen Humphrey, Fred Mozzocio, Mary Ann Tofel, Anna Pascarella and Olson voted for the contract. Mark Kirkwood, Dr. Marilyn K. Berkely and Barbara Razzano were against the move.
In Monday’s work session, Kirkwood and Berkely said they were opposed to Eckles Construction looking for a construction manager who would work with Eckles Architecture & Engineering. The district had hired Eckles Architecture to design the project.
Eckles Architecture and Eckles Construction are separate businesses, but there are overlapping ownership interests.
Razzano said previously she would not back motions involving the project, which she had voted against.
The companies that will be reviewed are Pathline Inc., Altoona; Chronicle Consulting LLC, Pittsburgh; GP Construction Inc., Edinburg; Massaro Construction Management Services, Pittsburgh; Scaparotti Construction Group, Cleveland; P.J. Dick Inc., Pittsburgh; and Thomas & Williamson, Pittsburgh.
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A revised proposal will trim $2,000 in consultant fees that the New Castle Area School District has to pay.
During its regular session last night, the school board voted 6-3 to hire John M. Pappas of Eckles Construction Services. Pappas will advise the district in the selection of a construction manager to oversee a $19 million renovation and creation of an early learning center at the site of the Harry W. Lockley Kindergarten Center.
The district originally negotiated a $6,500 contract. Pappas would have reviewed 16 of the 18 proposals submitted.
When the board agreed to reject bids exceeding $500,000, that left seven companies to consider. Board member Brad Olson proposed that Pappas lower his fee.
“I just renegotiated with a smaller scope of work,” business manager Joseph Ambrosini said. “He didn’t need to put in the time for those over $500,000.”
Pappas reduced his the cost of his services to $4,500.
Board members J. Allan Joseph, Karen Humphrey, Fred Mozzocio, Mary Ann Tofel, Anna Pascarella and Olson voted for the contract. Mark Kirkwood, Dr. Marilyn K. Berkely and Barbara Razzano were against the move.
In Monday’s work session, Kirkwood and Berkely said they were opposed to Eckles Construction looking for a construction manager who would work with Eckles Architecture & Engineering. The district had hired Eckles Architecture to design the project.
Eckles Architecture and Eckles Construction are separate businesses, but there are overlapping ownership interests.
Razzano said previously she would not back motions involving the project, which she had voted against.
The companies that will be reviewed are Pathline Inc., Altoona; Chronicle Consulting LLC, Pittsburgh; GP Construction Inc., Edinburg; Massaro Construction Management Services, Pittsburgh; Scaparotti Construction Group, Cleveland; P.J. Dick Inc., Pittsburgh; and Thomas & Williamson, Pittsburgh.
Lawsuit demands fiscal records
Jan. 13, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A New Castle school board member filed suit Monday to force the district to comply with a state agency’s ruling.
Barbara Razzano’s records request concerns the operation of the city’s youth football league, which is supervised by Red Hurricane head coach Frank Bongivengo Jr.
Yesterday, Lawrence County District Attorney Joshua Lamancusa said he was pursuing criminal prosecution of Bongivengo through the state Attorney General’s Office. Lamancusa said a state police investigation involving the coach’s reported use of league funds prompted the action.
The Office of Open Records ruled April 12, 2010, that Razzano was entitled to financial records and other documents regarding the youth football program.
The agency lacks enforcement powers. However, its rulings are binding. Razzano’s attorney, Ronald D. Barber, entered a petition with the county common pleas court to implement the Office of Open Records’ decision.
Razzano asked for the following items: an original bank statement with balance totals and check descriptions; deposit slips, bank information from March 12, 2008, through June 17, 2009; a list of all signers for banking; and the minutes and names/titles of the executive committee.
“We gave them all records,” district solicitor Charles Sapienza Jr. said in October 2010. “We never possessed, controlled or created those records.”
He added the district never objected to disclosing the information.
Bongivengo and board member Mark Kirkwood each possessed records involving league operations. Those were turned over to the district.
The agency noted in its decision that the district entered into a relationship with the league in March 2008. When it did, “the district assumed operational and financial oversight.”
Ultimately, New Castle was required to gain control of the records, the agency said.
In his petition, Barber reiterated the district failed to fulfill Razzano’s request.
“There is no sufficient excuse to justify this,” he said.
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A New Castle school board member filed suit Monday to force the district to comply with a state agency’s ruling.
Barbara Razzano’s records request concerns the operation of the city’s youth football league, which is supervised by Red Hurricane head coach Frank Bongivengo Jr.
Yesterday, Lawrence County District Attorney Joshua Lamancusa said he was pursuing criminal prosecution of Bongivengo through the state Attorney General’s Office. Lamancusa said a state police investigation involving the coach’s reported use of league funds prompted the action.
The Office of Open Records ruled April 12, 2010, that Razzano was entitled to financial records and other documents regarding the youth football program.
The agency lacks enforcement powers. However, its rulings are binding. Razzano’s attorney, Ronald D. Barber, entered a petition with the county common pleas court to implement the Office of Open Records’ decision.
Razzano asked for the following items: an original bank statement with balance totals and check descriptions; deposit slips, bank information from March 12, 2008, through June 17, 2009; a list of all signers for banking; and the minutes and names/titles of the executive committee.
“We gave them all records,” district solicitor Charles Sapienza Jr. said in October 2010. “We never possessed, controlled or created those records.”
He added the district never objected to disclosing the information.
Bongivengo and board member Mark Kirkwood each possessed records involving league operations. Those were turned over to the district.
The agency noted in its decision that the district entered into a relationship with the league in March 2008. When it did, “the district assumed operational and financial oversight.”
Ultimately, New Castle was required to gain control of the records, the agency said.
In his petition, Barber reiterated the district failed to fulfill Razzano’s request.
“There is no sufficient excuse to justify this,” he said.
Friday, January 28, 2011
Penalty?
Jan. 13, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Lawrence County’s district attorney has asked the state Attorney General’s Office to prosecute New Castle High’s head football coach.
Joshua Lamancusa said a state police investigation found alleged improper activity regarding Frank Bongivengo Jr.’s handling of the city youth football league’s finances.
“I’ve reviewed the content,” he said. “(State police) basically uncovered evidence that’s best handled by the criminal justice system.”
Lamancusa declined to discuss the elements of the case.
“It’s still a criminal investigation, and I’m bound by that,” he said. “I think (the state will) want to obtain additional information.”
Bongivengo requested and received control of the program in a 9-0 vote during a March 2008 school board meeting. The Tri-County Youth Football League had threatened to ban the city’s teams from participation unless they were under the district football program’s supervision, he said.
The squads feature students in grades three through six. The teams are not considered part of the district’s football program.
Bongivengo and his wife, Karen, handled league funds from March 2009 through July 2010. Frank Bongivengo Jr. was the primary signer on the football account. Now, a parents’ volunteer group oversees finances while Bongivengo supervises coaches in the program.
“I’ve reviewed all the records as well, along with the school board transcripts, and I don’t see anywhere where there’s any wrongdoing whatsoever,” said John Bongivengo, the coach’s attorney and a former district attorney.
John Bongivengo is a cousin of Frank Bongivengo Jr.
“The fact that it’s going to the Attorney General — I don’t think that changes anything as far as I’m concerned. If anything, he’s placed more money in that bank account than has ever been reimbursed to him.”
Frank Bongivengo Jr. also gained approval to operate Taggart Stadium concession stands, along with the district’s cheerleaders. He said the funds would be allocated for the youth and district programs.
New Castle provided an initial $23,000 contribution to buy equipment and pay vendors owed money from the former city league.
With the district attorney’s approval, state police obtained a search warrant June 25, 2010, for Frank and Karen Bongivengo Jr.’s personnel bank accounts at PNC Bank.
The warrant also focused on 12 airline tickets purchased for $3,146.40 in April 2009. They were paid from the youth football league’s account, the state police said.
During a July 2010 interview with the New Castle News, Frank Bongivengo said the transaction “was a simple, honest mistake that was rectified.”
The tickets were for a graduation trip to Florida that included Bongivengo’s son, Michael, and 11 classmates. The students gave Karen Bongivengo money for the trip. Expecting a price increase, she ordered the tickets.
“We received the confirmation from the airlines on April 13,” the coach said. “On the same day we realized we had given them the wrong numbers.
“It was simply a matter of grabbing the wrong card.”
Karen Bongivengo made two deposits totaling $2,470.70 into the football account April 13 after the transaction occurred. The money was returned in full by July 3.
“The remaining monies came in from the kids that hadn’t paid (prior to April 13),” said Frank Bongivengo Jr., who was hired as head football coach in June 2005.
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Lawrence County’s district attorney has asked the state Attorney General’s Office to prosecute New Castle High’s head football coach.
Joshua Lamancusa said a state police investigation found alleged improper activity regarding Frank Bongivengo Jr.’s handling of the city youth football league’s finances.
“I’ve reviewed the content,” he said. “(State police) basically uncovered evidence that’s best handled by the criminal justice system.”
Lamancusa declined to discuss the elements of the case.
“It’s still a criminal investigation, and I’m bound by that,” he said. “I think (the state will) want to obtain additional information.”
Bongivengo requested and received control of the program in a 9-0 vote during a March 2008 school board meeting. The Tri-County Youth Football League had threatened to ban the city’s teams from participation unless they were under the district football program’s supervision, he said.
The squads feature students in grades three through six. The teams are not considered part of the district’s football program.
Bongivengo and his wife, Karen, handled league funds from March 2009 through July 2010. Frank Bongivengo Jr. was the primary signer on the football account. Now, a parents’ volunteer group oversees finances while Bongivengo supervises coaches in the program.
“I’ve reviewed all the records as well, along with the school board transcripts, and I don’t see anywhere where there’s any wrongdoing whatsoever,” said John Bongivengo, the coach’s attorney and a former district attorney.
John Bongivengo is a cousin of Frank Bongivengo Jr.
“The fact that it’s going to the Attorney General — I don’t think that changes anything as far as I’m concerned. If anything, he’s placed more money in that bank account than has ever been reimbursed to him.”
Frank Bongivengo Jr. also gained approval to operate Taggart Stadium concession stands, along with the district’s cheerleaders. He said the funds would be allocated for the youth and district programs.
New Castle provided an initial $23,000 contribution to buy equipment and pay vendors owed money from the former city league.
With the district attorney’s approval, state police obtained a search warrant June 25, 2010, for Frank and Karen Bongivengo Jr.’s personnel bank accounts at PNC Bank.
The warrant also focused on 12 airline tickets purchased for $3,146.40 in April 2009. They were paid from the youth football league’s account, the state police said.
During a July 2010 interview with the New Castle News, Frank Bongivengo said the transaction “was a simple, honest mistake that was rectified.”
The tickets were for a graduation trip to Florida that included Bongivengo’s son, Michael, and 11 classmates. The students gave Karen Bongivengo money for the trip. Expecting a price increase, she ordered the tickets.
“We received the confirmation from the airlines on April 13,” the coach said. “On the same day we realized we had given them the wrong numbers.
“It was simply a matter of grabbing the wrong card.”
Karen Bongivengo made two deposits totaling $2,470.70 into the football account April 13 after the transaction occurred. The money was returned in full by July 3.
“The remaining monies came in from the kids that hadn’t paid (prior to April 13),” said Frank Bongivengo Jr., who was hired as head football coach in June 2005.
INSPIRED
Jan. 12, 2011
VICTIM OF FATAL
FIRE REMEMBERED AS A
TALENTED PAINTER, SCULPTOR.
INSPIRED
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
George Retkes prepared to work on a self-portrait in his grandfather’s Union Township home.
Nicholas L. Berbenczy noticed.
“I set up mirror and easel and just went at it,” the St. Petersburg, Fla., resident recalled. “He would come by every now and then and give me some comments.
The artistic appraisal was direct and given in Hungarian: What the heck was he doing? That looked awful. Why was he using that color?
“He did have valuable advice,” Retkes said of his experience in 2006. “And if I didn’t agree with it, I would assert my own opinion.”
A prominent porcelain painter, Berbenczy did not lack for talent, confidence or opinions.
The 90-year-old artist died of smoke inhalation during a house fire that occurred around 5:15 p.m. Jan. 3. The state police fire marshal is investigating the cause.
Specializing in handpainted ceramics, Berbenczy earned the status of master painter while in Hungary. He arrived in the United States in 1969 and used his skills at the former Shenanago China and the Franklin Mint.
“He leaned toward the realistic, picture-perfect kind of things,” his grandson said. “That’s very much what he was involved with.
“He was very skilled in his trade.”
Berbenczy designed plates for presidents and focused on his gifts as a painter and sculptor.
“In this area, nobody is doing what I am doing,” the Cameron Avenue resident told the New Castle News in a March 2001 interview.
Retkes had graduated from a visual and performing arts school in Florida when he traveled north with his father, Gabor, for a two-month stay.
“He showed me some things here and there,” he said of his grandfather. “We talked about different art-related matters.
“I liked hearing the things he had to say and how he reacted toward certain works of art compared to other ones.”
Before arriving, Retkes had heard stories about the art displayed within the small, two-bedroom home.
“Covered from floor to ceiling, every wall had plates and paintings,” he said. “Every drawer was full of little sculptures and stuff.
“When we weren’t busy, I spent a lot of time looking around. It’s pretty crazy to see that magnitude of work.”
Berbenczy didn’t permit retirement to hamper his creativity.
“He was 90 but an active 90,” said Zoltan Novak, a friend and fellow Hungarian. “He wasn’t one to sit around and do nothing.
“He (had) a lot of unfinished business.”
Novak, who lived nearby on Grandview Avenue, said Berbenczy shifted his emphasis. Painting porcelain proved difficult in his later years.
“His hands, once in a while, started to shake,” Novak said. “If he made a mistake, the whole thing was ruined, and he would have to (trash) it.
“He focused on painting pictures.”
Novak said he and his longtime friend met for coffee two to three times a week. On the day Berbenczy died, the pair spoke for 90 minutes before Novak left around 4:30 p.m.
“(Berbenczy) said he was lazy and that he had to go back to work.”
VICTIM OF FATAL
FIRE REMEMBERED AS A
TALENTED PAINTER, SCULPTOR.
INSPIRED
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
George Retkes prepared to work on a self-portrait in his grandfather’s Union Township home.
Nicholas L. Berbenczy noticed.
“I set up mirror and easel and just went at it,” the St. Petersburg, Fla., resident recalled. “He would come by every now and then and give me some comments.
The artistic appraisal was direct and given in Hungarian: What the heck was he doing? That looked awful. Why was he using that color?
“He did have valuable advice,” Retkes said of his experience in 2006. “And if I didn’t agree with it, I would assert my own opinion.”
A prominent porcelain painter, Berbenczy did not lack for talent, confidence or opinions.
The 90-year-old artist died of smoke inhalation during a house fire that occurred around 5:15 p.m. Jan. 3. The state police fire marshal is investigating the cause.
Specializing in handpainted ceramics, Berbenczy earned the status of master painter while in Hungary. He arrived in the United States in 1969 and used his skills at the former Shenanago China and the Franklin Mint.
“He leaned toward the realistic, picture-perfect kind of things,” his grandson said. “That’s very much what he was involved with.
“He was very skilled in his trade.”
Berbenczy designed plates for presidents and focused on his gifts as a painter and sculptor.
“In this area, nobody is doing what I am doing,” the Cameron Avenue resident told the New Castle News in a March 2001 interview.
Retkes had graduated from a visual and performing arts school in Florida when he traveled north with his father, Gabor, for a two-month stay.
“He showed me some things here and there,” he said of his grandfather. “We talked about different art-related matters.
“I liked hearing the things he had to say and how he reacted toward certain works of art compared to other ones.”
Before arriving, Retkes had heard stories about the art displayed within the small, two-bedroom home.
“Covered from floor to ceiling, every wall had plates and paintings,” he said. “Every drawer was full of little sculptures and stuff.
“When we weren’t busy, I spent a lot of time looking around. It’s pretty crazy to see that magnitude of work.”
Berbenczy didn’t permit retirement to hamper his creativity.
“He was 90 but an active 90,” said Zoltan Novak, a friend and fellow Hungarian. “He wasn’t one to sit around and do nothing.
“He (had) a lot of unfinished business.”
Novak, who lived nearby on Grandview Avenue, said Berbenczy shifted his emphasis. Painting porcelain proved difficult in his later years.
“His hands, once in a while, started to shake,” Novak said. “If he made a mistake, the whole thing was ruined, and he would have to (trash) it.
“He focused on painting pictures.”
Novak said he and his longtime friend met for coffee two to three times a week. On the day Berbenczy died, the pair spoke for 90 minutes before Novak left around 4:30 p.m.
“(Berbenczy) said he was lazy and that he had to go back to work.”
Board eyes project consultant
Jan. 11, 2011
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
New Castle’s $19 million early learning center project attracted 18 companies wanting to be hired as construction manager.
A $6,500 contract and the choice of consultant could temporarily slow the selection.
Business manager Joseph Ambrosini had planned to ask school board members tomorrow night to hire Eckles Architecture & Engineering as the district’s adviser.
“I have no expertise in that area,” he said last night during the board’s work session. “(Superintendent George Gabriel) felt the same way. In conversation with Eckles, we thought it might be a good idea if we had someone review the proposals.”
Board members Mark Kirkwood and Dr. Marilyn Berkely were troubled with the recommendation.
Eckles Construction Services was one of the firms submitting a bid. The business is a separate entity from Eckles Architecture. However, some partners in Eckles Architecture have an ownership interest in Eckles Construction.
Gabriel said the administration and school board wanted to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest and declined to accept Eckles Construction’s proposal. A second company, Cornerstone Construction Management, had its proposal rejected for not providing requested materials.
“The whole reason we’re getting into this is that we didn’t want Eckles to work for Eckles,” Kirkwood said. “Now you’re having Eckles tell us who is going to work with Eckles.”
Gabriel rejected that assertion.
“At no point did I suggest Eckles was going to pick the construction manager. ... The board’s going to pick who to use.”
Berkely also questioned the agreement.
“I think what’s bothering me is Eckles. I don’t know. OK?” she said. “Eckles. Eckles. Eckles everything.
“So you’re just dealing with one company who’s doing everything, and you’re not bringing in anybody else to get any kind of other opinion or other view.”
Gabriel asked the group if they had another choice.
“If you have a name, we’ll pick ’em,” he said. “I don’t care who it is. I just think we need someone else who has expertise in the area.”
Anna Pascarella supported the idea of a consultant.
“It’s another set of eyes to look over this big project,” the board member said.
The 16 remaining proposals ranged from $307,509 (Pathline Inc., Altoona) to $981,692 (Heery International Inc., Cleveland). Eight of those surpassed $500,000.
Board member Brad Olson suggested the administration reject the high-end proposals. The move would reduce the time Eckles needed to assess the plans.
“Why are we going to pay someone $6,500 to review a bid proposal that we in no means ever are going to hire this firm? he asked. “It just doesn’t make sense. It’s throwing money at nothing.”
In a consensus vote that followed, the board instructed Ambrosini to meet with Eckles to renegotiate the preliminary contract.
THE CANDIDATES
Construction manager list
The following firms submitted proposals to serve as construction manager for the H.W. Lockley Early Learning Center project. Of the 18 proposals, the New Castle Area School District excluded two city firms from consideration — Cornerstone Construction Management and Eckles Construction Services.
Expressing interest were:
•Pathline Inc., Altoona — $307,509
•Chronicle Consulting LLC, Pittsburgh — $377,080
•GP Construction Inc., Edinburg — $397,678
•Massaro Construction Management Services, Pittsburgh — $456,140
•Scaparotti Construction Group, Cleveland — $466,851
•P.J. Dick Inc., Pittsburgh — $480,037
•Thomas & Williamson, Pittsburgh — $481,984
•Foreman Program & Construction Management Inc., Zelienople — $545,945
•Turner Construction Co., Pittsburgh — $551,315
•Whiting-Turner Contracting Co., Pittsburgh — $619,002
•Gannett Fleming Inc., Harrisburg — $630,789
•URS Corp., Pittsburgh — $660,087
•G. Stephens Inc., Akron, Ohio — $740,125
•Stantec Consulting Services Inc., Philadelphia —$800,000
•AMEC E&C Services Inc., Sewickley — $816,000
•Heery International Inc., Cleveland — $981,692
Source: New Castle Area School District
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
New Castle’s $19 million early learning center project attracted 18 companies wanting to be hired as construction manager.
A $6,500 contract and the choice of consultant could temporarily slow the selection.
Business manager Joseph Ambrosini had planned to ask school board members tomorrow night to hire Eckles Architecture & Engineering as the district’s adviser.
“I have no expertise in that area,” he said last night during the board’s work session. “(Superintendent George Gabriel) felt the same way. In conversation with Eckles, we thought it might be a good idea if we had someone review the proposals.”
Board members Mark Kirkwood and Dr. Marilyn Berkely were troubled with the recommendation.
Eckles Construction Services was one of the firms submitting a bid. The business is a separate entity from Eckles Architecture. However, some partners in Eckles Architecture have an ownership interest in Eckles Construction.
Gabriel said the administration and school board wanted to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest and declined to accept Eckles Construction’s proposal. A second company, Cornerstone Construction Management, had its proposal rejected for not providing requested materials.
“The whole reason we’re getting into this is that we didn’t want Eckles to work for Eckles,” Kirkwood said. “Now you’re having Eckles tell us who is going to work with Eckles.”
Gabriel rejected that assertion.
“At no point did I suggest Eckles was going to pick the construction manager. ... The board’s going to pick who to use.”
Berkely also questioned the agreement.
“I think what’s bothering me is Eckles. I don’t know. OK?” she said. “Eckles. Eckles. Eckles everything.
“So you’re just dealing with one company who’s doing everything, and you’re not bringing in anybody else to get any kind of other opinion or other view.”
Gabriel asked the group if they had another choice.
“If you have a name, we’ll pick ’em,” he said. “I don’t care who it is. I just think we need someone else who has expertise in the area.”
Anna Pascarella supported the idea of a consultant.
“It’s another set of eyes to look over this big project,” the board member said.
The 16 remaining proposals ranged from $307,509 (Pathline Inc., Altoona) to $981,692 (Heery International Inc., Cleveland). Eight of those surpassed $500,000.
Board member Brad Olson suggested the administration reject the high-end proposals. The move would reduce the time Eckles needed to assess the plans.
“Why are we going to pay someone $6,500 to review a bid proposal that we in no means ever are going to hire this firm? he asked. “It just doesn’t make sense. It’s throwing money at nothing.”
In a consensus vote that followed, the board instructed Ambrosini to meet with Eckles to renegotiate the preliminary contract.
THE CANDIDATES
Construction manager list
The following firms submitted proposals to serve as construction manager for the H.W. Lockley Early Learning Center project. Of the 18 proposals, the New Castle Area School District excluded two city firms from consideration — Cornerstone Construction Management and Eckles Construction Services.
Expressing interest were:
•Pathline Inc., Altoona — $307,509
•Chronicle Consulting LLC, Pittsburgh — $377,080
•GP Construction Inc., Edinburg — $397,678
•Massaro Construction Management Services, Pittsburgh — $456,140
•Scaparotti Construction Group, Cleveland — $466,851
•P.J. Dick Inc., Pittsburgh — $480,037
•Thomas & Williamson, Pittsburgh — $481,984
•Foreman Program & Construction Management Inc., Zelienople — $545,945
•Turner Construction Co., Pittsburgh — $551,315
•Whiting-Turner Contracting Co., Pittsburgh — $619,002
•Gannett Fleming Inc., Harrisburg — $630,789
•URS Corp., Pittsburgh — $660,087
•G. Stephens Inc., Akron, Ohio — $740,125
•Stantec Consulting Services Inc., Philadelphia —$800,000
•AMEC E&C Services Inc., Sewickley — $816,000
•Heery International Inc., Cleveland — $981,692
Source: New Castle Area School District
Leap of faith
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Daniel Sepulveda recalled the moments after the Pittsburgh Steelers won the AFC Championship Game.
“Everybody’s high-fiving one another,” he said of the Jan. 23 clash with the New York Jets. “We’re all excited. They’re playing ‘Pittsburgh’s Going to the Super Bowl.’ It’s just incredible.
“And I’m sitting there in sweat pants and a sweat shirt. It’s just eating me up. I knew this moment was coming. I’d been there before. It’s a hard place to be.”
Injuries to his right leg have knocked the Pittsburgh punter out of two Super Bowls.
The first occurred in 2009 when the Steelers beat the Arizona Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII. The next one, Super Bowl XLV, will take place Feb. 6 when Pittsburgh plays Green Bay at Cowboys Stadium in Arlington, Texas.
Sepulveda talked about the experience last night at Westminster College’s Wallace Memorial Chapel. The event was presented by the college’s Office of the Chaplain and Church Relations and Fellowship of Christian Athletes.
A reporter reminded Sepulveda of his “misfortune” during an interview yesterday, he told the audience of approximately 250.
“You must feel like the most unlucky guy in football,” the Baylor University graduate was told.
He disagreed.
“God’s been so good to me in my life. I’ve been able to play football since fourth grade, and I’m still playing now. There’s nothing unlucky about my life.”
Sepulveda entered the NFL in 2007. A damaged anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee shelved him during the Steelers’ Super Bowl title run for the entire 2008 campaign.
He played 12 games this season before suffering the same injury in a 13-10 win against Baltimore.
“Sure, if you look at my circumstances, what a bummer,” he said. “I can’t turn around without being reminded of that truth.”
Faith in God has allowed him to maintain his Christian attitude and perspective. He credited his parents for placing him on that path.
“They are, and have been, an incredible blessing,” he said. “They raised me and my three brothers in a Christian home.”
Sepulveda referenced 1 Samuel when talking about what God sees compared to humankind. He said the world’s eyes will be on the players and their jerseys when the Super Bowl takes place.
God ignores the outward appearance and looks at one’s heart.
“That verse is going to hit so close to home for me the next couple weeks of my life,” he said.
“I desperately wish I could wear that jersey. That’s just not God’s will for my life right now. It wasn’t a couple of years from now, and it’s not now.”
The one thing he won’t accept is that he’s unlucky.
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Daniel Sepulveda recalled the moments after the Pittsburgh Steelers won the AFC Championship Game.
“Everybody’s high-fiving one another,” he said of the Jan. 23 clash with the New York Jets. “We’re all excited. They’re playing ‘Pittsburgh’s Going to the Super Bowl.’ It’s just incredible.
“And I’m sitting there in sweat pants and a sweat shirt. It’s just eating me up. I knew this moment was coming. I’d been there before. It’s a hard place to be.”
Injuries to his right leg have knocked the Pittsburgh punter out of two Super Bowls.
The first occurred in 2009 when the Steelers beat the Arizona Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII. The next one, Super Bowl XLV, will take place Feb. 6 when Pittsburgh plays Green Bay at Cowboys Stadium in Arlington, Texas.
Sepulveda talked about the experience last night at Westminster College’s Wallace Memorial Chapel. The event was presented by the college’s Office of the Chaplain and Church Relations and Fellowship of Christian Athletes.
A reporter reminded Sepulveda of his “misfortune” during an interview yesterday, he told the audience of approximately 250.
“You must feel like the most unlucky guy in football,” the Baylor University graduate was told.
He disagreed.
“God’s been so good to me in my life. I’ve been able to play football since fourth grade, and I’m still playing now. There’s nothing unlucky about my life.”
Sepulveda entered the NFL in 2007. A damaged anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee shelved him during the Steelers’ Super Bowl title run for the entire 2008 campaign.
He played 12 games this season before suffering the same injury in a 13-10 win against Baltimore.
“Sure, if you look at my circumstances, what a bummer,” he said. “I can’t turn around without being reminded of that truth.”
Faith in God has allowed him to maintain his Christian attitude and perspective. He credited his parents for placing him on that path.
“They are, and have been, an incredible blessing,” he said. “They raised me and my three brothers in a Christian home.”
Sepulveda referenced 1 Samuel when talking about what God sees compared to humankind. He said the world’s eyes will be on the players and their jerseys when the Super Bowl takes place.
God ignores the outward appearance and looks at one’s heart.
“That verse is going to hit so close to home for me the next couple weeks of my life,” he said.
“I desperately wish I could wear that jersey. That’s just not God’s will for my life right now. It wasn’t a couple of years from now, and it’s not now.”
The one thing he won’t accept is that he’s unlucky.
Monday, January 24, 2011
Child's condition improves
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A mother wanted to dispel rumors that the worst had happened to her 6-year-old son.
Instead, a Lockley Kindergarten Center student is looking toward a full recovery after being struck by a car Friday morning.
The family has requested anonymity but confirmed the child’s first name is Anthony.
“We thought the worst at the beginning,” his mother said. “He will recover. That’s my main concern.”
The child and his father were waiting for the school bus along with Anthony’s classmate and the classmate’s grandmother outside the Keystone Specialty Co., 1029 S. Mill St. Police said city resident Samuel Abraham III lost control of his Pontiac Bonneville when the accident occurred around 10:50 a.m.
Abraham’s car, which was traveling south, went into the northbound lane, over the curb and onto the sidewalk. The vehicle struck Anthony and the woman, who was reportedly not injured. Her name was not available.
Anthony is being treated at Children’s Hospital in Pittsburgh. His injuries include a fracture near the left eye and a concussion.
“He sleeps for long periods of time, and (the doctors) said that’s normal with any severe head injury,” his mother said. “If I ask him a question, he’ll answer me.”
Doctors have not said when he will be released.
The family moved from New Jersey to the city in November. Family members from New Jersey and Michigan have traveled to Pittsburgh to be with the youth.
Poor weather conditions forced county school districts to delay the start of classes by two hours Friday.
Police Chief Thomas Sansone said Abraham was taken to Jameson Hospital for a blood test.
“He claims the roads were slippery,” Sansone said Friday. “He also told officers that he had come from a methadone clinic.”
City police are continuing their investigation.
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A mother wanted to dispel rumors that the worst had happened to her 6-year-old son.
Instead, a Lockley Kindergarten Center student is looking toward a full recovery after being struck by a car Friday morning.
The family has requested anonymity but confirmed the child’s first name is Anthony.
“We thought the worst at the beginning,” his mother said. “He will recover. That’s my main concern.”
The child and his father were waiting for the school bus along with Anthony’s classmate and the classmate’s grandmother outside the Keystone Specialty Co., 1029 S. Mill St. Police said city resident Samuel Abraham III lost control of his Pontiac Bonneville when the accident occurred around 10:50 a.m.
Abraham’s car, which was traveling south, went into the northbound lane, over the curb and onto the sidewalk. The vehicle struck Anthony and the woman, who was reportedly not injured. Her name was not available.
Anthony is being treated at Children’s Hospital in Pittsburgh. His injuries include a fracture near the left eye and a concussion.
“He sleeps for long periods of time, and (the doctors) said that’s normal with any severe head injury,” his mother said. “If I ask him a question, he’ll answer me.”
Doctors have not said when he will be released.
The family moved from New Jersey to the city in November. Family members from New Jersey and Michigan have traveled to Pittsburgh to be with the youth.
Poor weather conditions forced county school districts to delay the start of classes by two hours Friday.
Police Chief Thomas Sansone said Abraham was taken to Jameson Hospital for a blood test.
“He claims the roads were slippery,” Sansone said Friday. “He also told officers that he had come from a methadone clinic.”
City police are continuing their investigation.
Youth wanted to live with dad
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A New Castle youth wanted to live with his father months before he was killed.
Tomislav “Tommy” Novosel’s family made the claim in a first-person obituary written on behalf of the 12-year-old.
Lawrence County Coroner Russell Noga said Saturday that Ljuba Novosel, 40, shot her son and mother Anka Denk, 81, each in the head while they slept in their upstairs bedrooms.
She then killed herself with a .38-caliber revolver. Her body was found at the bottom of the first-floor stairway. Noga said she had purchased the gun in 2009.
City police discovered the bodies Friday when they were called to 816 S. Mercer St. to check on the welfare of the family. Noga said he believes the deaths occurred between 11 p.m. and midnight Wednesday.
Pathologist Dr. James Smith, Noga and two city detectives conducted the autopsies Saturday morning at the Beaver Valley Medical Center. Noga ruled the deaths as a double homicide/suicide.
City police Chief Thomas Sansone said this morning that Novosel did not leave a suicide note.
“(My) family is all in Ellwood City, that’s why in October of 2010 I decided to move to Ellwood City,” the obituary said. “I told my dad that I packed my bags. Unfortunately, I didn’t have time to finish that paper what you call a Petition.”
Ljuba Novosel had divorced Tomislav Novosel in 2000. The pair married in Zagreb, Croatia, on Sept. 24, 1994, according to Lawrence County court records.
“I had two homes, one in New Castle where I lived with my mom and one in Ellwood City where I lived with my dad,” according to the seventh-grader’s obituary. “Ever since I was little I loved being with my family in Ellwood City and enjoyed playing with my cousins.”
He attended New Castle Junior/Senior High School and belonged to Holy Redeemer Church in Ellwood City.
“He was very proud of being an altar server,” the Rev. Mark L. Thomas said this morning. “He took great joy in coming here.”
Thomas said he has known the youth and his father since 1999. The priest will conduct the Mass of Christian burial Thursday morning.
Ljuba Novosel and her family were somewhat of a mystery to their South Side neighbors.
“Some people recalled them and some don’t,” said the Rev. John Petrarulo of St. Vitus Church. “I really can’t put my finger on it.
“All I know is they were two doors down, and I never saw them.”
A few residents thought the family had lived on South Mercer Street a short time, while others’ memories of them go back at least three years.
Some neighbors were under the impression the Novosels had moved to Ellwood City.
Kira Walthall said she last saw the family during the summer.
“They were a very quiet family,” she said. “They stayed to themselves.”
Ljuba Novosel, who became an American citizen in 1998, was a registered nurse. According to the Pennsylvania Department of State website, she renewed her license in October.
She graduated from Slippery Rock University’s nursing program in 2005, a university spokesman said this morning.
“We never know what a person’s problems are, what difficulties they’re living in,” Petrarulo said of the deaths. “As far as the community is involved, they’re shocked, especially when a young person is involved.”
City police are continuing their investigation. The gun will be sent for testing, Sansone said. He said officers recovered three shells from the five-chamber revolver at the scene. The two remaining bullets were still in the gun’s chamber.
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
A New Castle youth wanted to live with his father months before he was killed.
Tomislav “Tommy” Novosel’s family made the claim in a first-person obituary written on behalf of the 12-year-old.
Lawrence County Coroner Russell Noga said Saturday that Ljuba Novosel, 40, shot her son and mother Anka Denk, 81, each in the head while they slept in their upstairs bedrooms.
She then killed herself with a .38-caliber revolver. Her body was found at the bottom of the first-floor stairway. Noga said she had purchased the gun in 2009.
City police discovered the bodies Friday when they were called to 816 S. Mercer St. to check on the welfare of the family. Noga said he believes the deaths occurred between 11 p.m. and midnight Wednesday.
Pathologist Dr. James Smith, Noga and two city detectives conducted the autopsies Saturday morning at the Beaver Valley Medical Center. Noga ruled the deaths as a double homicide/suicide.
City police Chief Thomas Sansone said this morning that Novosel did not leave a suicide note.
“(My) family is all in Ellwood City, that’s why in October of 2010 I decided to move to Ellwood City,” the obituary said. “I told my dad that I packed my bags. Unfortunately, I didn’t have time to finish that paper what you call a Petition.”
Ljuba Novosel had divorced Tomislav Novosel in 2000. The pair married in Zagreb, Croatia, on Sept. 24, 1994, according to Lawrence County court records.
“I had two homes, one in New Castle where I lived with my mom and one in Ellwood City where I lived with my dad,” according to the seventh-grader’s obituary. “Ever since I was little I loved being with my family in Ellwood City and enjoyed playing with my cousins.”
He attended New Castle Junior/Senior High School and belonged to Holy Redeemer Church in Ellwood City.
“He was very proud of being an altar server,” the Rev. Mark L. Thomas said this morning. “He took great joy in coming here.”
Thomas said he has known the youth and his father since 1999. The priest will conduct the Mass of Christian burial Thursday morning.
Ljuba Novosel and her family were somewhat of a mystery to their South Side neighbors.
“Some people recalled them and some don’t,” said the Rev. John Petrarulo of St. Vitus Church. “I really can’t put my finger on it.
“All I know is they were two doors down, and I never saw them.”
A few residents thought the family had lived on South Mercer Street a short time, while others’ memories of them go back at least three years.
Some neighbors were under the impression the Novosels had moved to Ellwood City.
Kira Walthall said she last saw the family during the summer.
“They were a very quiet family,” she said. “They stayed to themselves.”
Ljuba Novosel, who became an American citizen in 1998, was a registered nurse. According to the Pennsylvania Department of State website, she renewed her license in October.
She graduated from Slippery Rock University’s nursing program in 2005, a university spokesman said this morning.
“We never know what a person’s problems are, what difficulties they’re living in,” Petrarulo said of the deaths. “As far as the community is involved, they’re shocked, especially when a young person is involved.”
City police are continuing their investigation. The gun will be sent for testing, Sansone said. He said officers recovered three shells from the five-chamber revolver at the scene. The two remaining bullets were still in the gun’s chamber.
Friday, January 21, 2011
Board approves offer for land
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
The New Castle Area School District will learn if it is working with a motivated seller.
In a special session yesterday afternoon, the school board authorized the district to offer $90,000 for approximately 20 acres owned by Solid Rock Ministry of New Castle Inc. The vacant property, which borders North Scott Street, will be used as part of the $19 million renovation of the Lockley Kindergarten Center. The new facility, the H.W. Lockley Early Learning Center, will house students in kindergarten through second grade.
James Manolis, attorney for Solid Rock Ministry, said last night he wanted to review the offer and discuss it with his client before commenting.
As part of the renovation project, the Pennsylvania Department of Education required appraisals from two independent firms. Richard G. English & Associates of Sharon said the site was worth $80,000. Infinity Valuations & Appraisals of Fombell pegged the value at $90,000.
Business manager Joseph Ambrosini said the district must offer the higher of the two amounts to the property owner. The state will give the district $58,500, which is 65 percent of the $90,000 offer. If the sides agree to a higher amount, Ambrosini said there would be no additional reimbursement.
Solid Rock Ministry purchased the land for $35,000 in January 1997. Applying the U.S. Consumer Price Index, the transaction would equate to $47,500 in 2010.
Last year, the county assessed the property at $21,400. The ministry’s city, county and school taxes amounted to approximately $1,100.
Promises for Pets, an animal advocate organization, offered $125,000 to Solid Rock Ministry in May 2009. The group wanted to build a no-kill shelter on the site but rescinded its agreement after learning of the possible Lockley expansion.
Under the direction of former board President Donna Donati, a community-based group was formed in 2008 to review New Castle’s facility needs.
Voting for the measure were J. Allan Joseph, Karen Humphrey, Fred Mozzocio, Brad Olson Jr., Anna Pascarella and Mary Ann Tofel. Humphrey participated in the meeting by phone. Members Mark Kirkwood, Barbara Razzano and Dr. Marilyn K. Berkely were absent.
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
The New Castle Area School District will learn if it is working with a motivated seller.
In a special session yesterday afternoon, the school board authorized the district to offer $90,000 for approximately 20 acres owned by Solid Rock Ministry of New Castle Inc. The vacant property, which borders North Scott Street, will be used as part of the $19 million renovation of the Lockley Kindergarten Center. The new facility, the H.W. Lockley Early Learning Center, will house students in kindergarten through second grade.
James Manolis, attorney for Solid Rock Ministry, said last night he wanted to review the offer and discuss it with his client before commenting.
As part of the renovation project, the Pennsylvania Department of Education required appraisals from two independent firms. Richard G. English & Associates of Sharon said the site was worth $80,000. Infinity Valuations & Appraisals of Fombell pegged the value at $90,000.
Business manager Joseph Ambrosini said the district must offer the higher of the two amounts to the property owner. The state will give the district $58,500, which is 65 percent of the $90,000 offer. If the sides agree to a higher amount, Ambrosini said there would be no additional reimbursement.
Solid Rock Ministry purchased the land for $35,000 in January 1997. Applying the U.S. Consumer Price Index, the transaction would equate to $47,500 in 2010.
Last year, the county assessed the property at $21,400. The ministry’s city, county and school taxes amounted to approximately $1,100.
Promises for Pets, an animal advocate organization, offered $125,000 to Solid Rock Ministry in May 2009. The group wanted to build a no-kill shelter on the site but rescinded its agreement after learning of the possible Lockley expansion.
Under the direction of former board President Donna Donati, a community-based group was formed in 2008 to review New Castle’s facility needs.
Voting for the measure were J. Allan Joseph, Karen Humphrey, Fred Mozzocio, Brad Olson Jr., Anna Pascarella and Mary Ann Tofel. Humphrey participated in the meeting by phone. Members Mark Kirkwood, Barbara Razzano and Dr. Marilyn K. Berkely were absent.
Monday, January 3, 2011
Deadly year
Jan. 1, 2011
(As 2010 draws to a close, The News is counting down the Top 10 local stories of the year. Today: No. 1)
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
With six possible homicides occurring in New Castle during the past year, the city tops an undesirable list.
A survey of 14 communities similar in size finds New Castle ranks first with McKeesport in number of murders.
“I remember working a lot of homicides, but I don’t remember that kind of a number,” said police Chief Thomas Sansone, a veteran of 25 years.
The number of deaths investigated by Sansone’s department is an unusual amount for a city of approximately 24,500.
Prior to 2010, the highest number of murders in the city occurred in 2005 when four were reported.
One ongoing investigation here involves a 71-year-old man who died in a wooded area.
“We don’t know if we can call it a (hunting) accident or not,” said Sansone.
“There really is no rhyme or reason as to whether you have an increase or decrease in murders in a given year,” Sansone said.
THE CASES
Following is the list of victims.
•Kaelin Davis, 11 months old, of Halco Drive died on May 31. The cause of death was ruled blunt force trauma to the head.
Facing five charges, including criminal homicide, the 23-year-old William Henry Hess Jr. is being held without bail in the Lawrence County jail. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for 1 p.m. Jan. 12.
•Frank James Breitenstein, 45, of Volant died the evening of Aug. 28 near 314 Bell Ave. Breitenstein was shot with a BB gun after he confronted a male youth shooting at houses.
A BB was removed from Breitenstein’s lung during his autopsy. No one has been charged in the death, but police have identified two potential suspects.
•Melvin Harper, 26, of New Castle died as the results of gunshot wounds. His death occurred between 2 and 3 a.m. Sept. 17 in the parking lot of Wise Guyz, 1115 N. Croton Ave.
Davven Eric Malloy, 20, of Pittsburgh, was wanted in connection with Harper’s death. He committed suicide around midnight Nov. 22 at a Westover, W.Va., motel.
•Edward Wooten, 39, of Parkwood Court was killed as the result of a single gunshot to the abdomen. The incident took place around 2:25 a.m. Nov. 21 in the parking lot of the Players Lounge, a South Mill Street bar. Wooten died at Jameson Hospital.
Michael L. Williams, 34, was arrested Dec. 10. Williams, who lists addresses on South Liberty Street and in Sharpsville, is in county jail on eight charges that include criminal homicide and aggravated assault. Williams’ court hearing is slated for 1 p.m. Jan. 27.
•Trevaughn Lamont Thompson, 19, of Westview Terrace was killed following a volley of gunfire around 11:30 a.m. Nov. 30, 2010, while driving along Halco Drive. He was pronounced dead almost nine hours later at Youngstown’s St. Elizabeth Health Center.
City police charged Tavin Lamar Wise, 19, of Halco Drive with 26 offenses that include criminal homicide and aggravated assault. He is being held without bail in the county jail. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for 1 p.m. Jan. 6.
•Leroy W. Blashak Jr., 71, of 310 Montgomery Ave. died Nov. 29. His body was found in a Mahoningtown field. Police said a bullet entered Blashak’s right shoulder.
Authorities are working with the Pennsylvania Game Commission to determine if the shooting involved a hunter and if it was intentional.
THE POLICE
No connection is apparent among the deaths. In the killings of Harper, Thompson and Wooten, Sansone said that a common group of family, friends and acquaintances existed among the three. However, that played no role in their murders.
“It’s just a coincidence,” he said.
Nor is an influx of weapons to blame.
“I think they’ve always been available. The people that do have them aren’t thinking. They’re just pulling them out and using them.”
A state study conducted as part of the city’s financial recovery plan backs Sansone’s view that the department is understaffed. Last year, New Castle had 35 full-time and three part-time officers. Ten more are needed.
“Naturally, we can’t afford it,” he said. “However, that shows our officers are doing a good job with the manpower they have.”
Sansone also countered a perception that New Castle is a place where people can get away with murder. Excluding the Blashak investigation, charges have been filed in all but three cases dating back to 2005.
“We do have suspects, but we just need enough information to file the charge and that’s where we’re stuck. I think our clearance rate for what we’re dealing with is pretty good.”
Sansone said his officers will continue to patrol high crime areas in an effort to keep those sections under control.
“Are you going to prevent it? Not necessarily,” Sansone said. “It takes about 10 seconds to murder someone.”
COMPARISON
Homicides by city
Following are the number of homicides committed in Pennsylvania communities of similar size to New Castle, which had an approximate population of 24,500 in 2009. The totals are from Jan. 1, 2010, through Dec. 28, 2010.
•McKeesport 6
•New Castle 6*
•Lebanon 4
•Easton 1
•Horsham Township (Montgomery County) 1
•Susquehanna Township (Dauphin County) 1
•Johnstown 0
•Marple Township (Delaware County)
•Montgomery Township (Montgomery County) 0
•Springettsbury Township (York County) 0
•Spring Township (Berks County) 0
•Tredyffrin Township (Chester County) 0
•Upper Dublin Township (Montgomery County) 0
•Upper Moreland Township (Montgomery County) 0
*(Includes one death that is under investigation as a possible hunting accident)
Pittsburgh reported 57 murders in 2010. The city, with approximately 312,000 residents, is an hour south of New Castle.
Twenty killings occurred in Youngstown during 2010. Located 20 minutes northeast of New Castle, Youngstown has a population of approximately 72,000.
(Sources: Right-to-know requests filed with the above police departments, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, the Youngstown Police Department and New Castle News archives.)
THROUGH THE YEARS
New Castle killings
•2000 – 2
•2001 – 2
•2002 – 2
•2003 – 2
•2004 – 3
•2005 – 4
•2006 – 3
•2007 – 1
•2008 – 2
•2009 – 2
•2010 – 6*
*(includes one death that is under investigation as a possible hunting accident.)
(Sources: New Castle police department and the Pennsylvania Uniform Crime Reporting System)
(As 2010 draws to a close, The News is counting down the Top 10 local stories of the year. Today: No. 1)
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
With six possible homicides occurring in New Castle during the past year, the city tops an undesirable list.
A survey of 14 communities similar in size finds New Castle ranks first with McKeesport in number of murders.
“I remember working a lot of homicides, but I don’t remember that kind of a number,” said police Chief Thomas Sansone, a veteran of 25 years.
The number of deaths investigated by Sansone’s department is an unusual amount for a city of approximately 24,500.
Prior to 2010, the highest number of murders in the city occurred in 2005 when four were reported.
One ongoing investigation here involves a 71-year-old man who died in a wooded area.
“We don’t know if we can call it a (hunting) accident or not,” said Sansone.
“There really is no rhyme or reason as to whether you have an increase or decrease in murders in a given year,” Sansone said.
THE CASES
Following is the list of victims.
•Kaelin Davis, 11 months old, of Halco Drive died on May 31. The cause of death was ruled blunt force trauma to the head.
Facing five charges, including criminal homicide, the 23-year-old William Henry Hess Jr. is being held without bail in the Lawrence County jail. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for 1 p.m. Jan. 12.
•Frank James Breitenstein, 45, of Volant died the evening of Aug. 28 near 314 Bell Ave. Breitenstein was shot with a BB gun after he confronted a male youth shooting at houses.
A BB was removed from Breitenstein’s lung during his autopsy. No one has been charged in the death, but police have identified two potential suspects.
•Melvin Harper, 26, of New Castle died as the results of gunshot wounds. His death occurred between 2 and 3 a.m. Sept. 17 in the parking lot of Wise Guyz, 1115 N. Croton Ave.
Davven Eric Malloy, 20, of Pittsburgh, was wanted in connection with Harper’s death. He committed suicide around midnight Nov. 22 at a Westover, W.Va., motel.
•Edward Wooten, 39, of Parkwood Court was killed as the result of a single gunshot to the abdomen. The incident took place around 2:25 a.m. Nov. 21 in the parking lot of the Players Lounge, a South Mill Street bar. Wooten died at Jameson Hospital.
Michael L. Williams, 34, was arrested Dec. 10. Williams, who lists addresses on South Liberty Street and in Sharpsville, is in county jail on eight charges that include criminal homicide and aggravated assault. Williams’ court hearing is slated for 1 p.m. Jan. 27.
•Trevaughn Lamont Thompson, 19, of Westview Terrace was killed following a volley of gunfire around 11:30 a.m. Nov. 30, 2010, while driving along Halco Drive. He was pronounced dead almost nine hours later at Youngstown’s St. Elizabeth Health Center.
City police charged Tavin Lamar Wise, 19, of Halco Drive with 26 offenses that include criminal homicide and aggravated assault. He is being held without bail in the county jail. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for 1 p.m. Jan. 6.
•Leroy W. Blashak Jr., 71, of 310 Montgomery Ave. died Nov. 29. His body was found in a Mahoningtown field. Police said a bullet entered Blashak’s right shoulder.
Authorities are working with the Pennsylvania Game Commission to determine if the shooting involved a hunter and if it was intentional.
THE POLICE
No connection is apparent among the deaths. In the killings of Harper, Thompson and Wooten, Sansone said that a common group of family, friends and acquaintances existed among the three. However, that played no role in their murders.
“It’s just a coincidence,” he said.
Nor is an influx of weapons to blame.
“I think they’ve always been available. The people that do have them aren’t thinking. They’re just pulling them out and using them.”
A state study conducted as part of the city’s financial recovery plan backs Sansone’s view that the department is understaffed. Last year, New Castle had 35 full-time and three part-time officers. Ten more are needed.
“Naturally, we can’t afford it,” he said. “However, that shows our officers are doing a good job with the manpower they have.”
Sansone also countered a perception that New Castle is a place where people can get away with murder. Excluding the Blashak investigation, charges have been filed in all but three cases dating back to 2005.
“We do have suspects, but we just need enough information to file the charge and that’s where we’re stuck. I think our clearance rate for what we’re dealing with is pretty good.”
Sansone said his officers will continue to patrol high crime areas in an effort to keep those sections under control.
“Are you going to prevent it? Not necessarily,” Sansone said. “It takes about 10 seconds to murder someone.”
COMPARISON
Homicides by city
Following are the number of homicides committed in Pennsylvania communities of similar size to New Castle, which had an approximate population of 24,500 in 2009. The totals are from Jan. 1, 2010, through Dec. 28, 2010.
•McKeesport 6
•New Castle 6*
•Lebanon 4
•Easton 1
•Horsham Township (Montgomery County) 1
•Susquehanna Township (Dauphin County) 1
•Johnstown 0
•Marple Township (Delaware County)
•Montgomery Township (Montgomery County) 0
•Springettsbury Township (York County) 0
•Spring Township (Berks County) 0
•Tredyffrin Township (Chester County) 0
•Upper Dublin Township (Montgomery County) 0
•Upper Moreland Township (Montgomery County) 0
*(Includes one death that is under investigation as a possible hunting accident)
Pittsburgh reported 57 murders in 2010. The city, with approximately 312,000 residents, is an hour south of New Castle.
Twenty killings occurred in Youngstown during 2010. Located 20 minutes northeast of New Castle, Youngstown has a population of approximately 72,000.
(Sources: Right-to-know requests filed with the above police departments, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, the Youngstown Police Department and New Castle News archives.)
THROUGH THE YEARS
New Castle killings
•2000 – 2
•2001 – 2
•2002 – 2
•2003 – 2
•2004 – 3
•2005 – 4
•2006 – 3
•2007 – 1
•2008 – 2
•2009 – 2
•2010 – 6*
*(includes one death that is under investigation as a possible hunting accident.)
(Sources: New Castle police department and the Pennsylvania Uniform Crime Reporting System)
DeRosa plea caps federal probe
Dec. 31, 2010
(As 2010 draws to a close, The News is counting down the Top 10 local stories of the year. Today: No. 2)
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Who’s Nick DeRosa? What’s he like?
During its federal grand jury investigation into mortgage fraud, the U.S. Attorney’s Office questioned Deno DeLorenzo about the finances of Affordable Housing of Lawrence County. A few grand jury participants wanted to know about the retired New Castle school administrator.
“I was there for a good hour of questioning,” DeLorenzo said of his April 2008 testimony. “The only question (the jury) asked was about the character of Nick DeRosa.”
DeLorenzo served as board president in the final months of the nonprofit housing agency’s existence. While executive director of the Lawrence County housing authority, Robert Evanick helped found Affordable Housing in 2003.
He left the group in December 2005 after the board signed a $250,000 mortgage agreement with First Commonwealth Bank for the purchase of seven structures.
The agency defaulted on the loan in March 2006. DeRosa owned or co-owned four of the seven properties.
A certified public accountant, DeLorenzo provided the government with the documentation and insight that led to charges being filed against DeRosa and four other parties.
DeRosa pleaded guilty Oct. 28 to single felony counts of bank fraud, mail fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. His sentencing is scheduled for March 1.
IMAGE
The unfolding of the Affordable Housing scandal magnified the differences between DeRosa’s public image and private life.
He was elected to city council, served two terms on the Slippery Rock University Council of Trustees and sat on the Lawrence County Planning Commission board.
DeRosa’s community service included work with the American Heart Association, the American Cancer Society and Easter Seals. He also was former president of the National Association of Wolves, an Italian service organization.
However, DeRosa is best known for his association with the New Castle Area School District. A 1963 Ne-Ca-Hi graduate, he was hired as an elementary teacher. DeRosa was promoted to principal and became assistant superintendent in 1989.
Although never naming him, a 2003 state Auditor General’s report detailed problems involving the educator. The findings outlined gambling activities that permitted DeRosa to receive free hotel rooms for three school board members attending a conference in 2002; a failure to disclose financial interests; the purchase of boxed lunches from the district for a business DeRosa owned; and his conduct regarding travel while representing the school system.
The audit led the school board to hire attorney Richard A. Harper in March 2004 to conduct an independent review.
“The Harper Report focuses on one thing and one thing only — the assistant superintendent (Nicholas DeRosa),” district solicitor Charles Sapienza said in a June 24, 2006, interview.
TARGET
Likewise, federal investigators made him the target of its mortgage fraud probe.
DeRosa originally pleaded not guilty to the charges. Prior to the change, defense attorney Efrem Grail filed objections to portions of the government’s evidence.
One of the complaints dealt with DeRosa’s role as a landlord.
Government investigators talked to former tenants, one of which referred to him as a “slumlord.” New Castle code enforcement had condemned a Wallace Avenue property that DeRosa co-owned five days after Castle Realty inspected it for an appraisal. Rats were reportedly living in the properties, and truckloads of trash were removed.
Federal prosecutors also were prepared to tie DeRosa to the theft of quarters from housing authority laundry machines, kickbacks involving a housing authority grass-cutting contract and money he and former county treasurer Gary Felasco reportedly collected from a bingo hall operator.
In court paperwork, Grail called the evidence improper and said that it tainted “Mr. DeRosa’s character in the eyes of the jury, to show he has a propensity to do wrong, to paint him as a bad person.”
DeRosa faces three to four years in prison, probation, restitution, forfeiture of assets and fines. He remains free on $10,000 unsecured bond.
(As 2010 draws to a close, The News is counting down the Top 10 local stories of the year. Today: No. 2)
By PATRICK E. LITOWITZ
plitowitz@ncnewsonline.com
Who’s Nick DeRosa? What’s he like?
During its federal grand jury investigation into mortgage fraud, the U.S. Attorney’s Office questioned Deno DeLorenzo about the finances of Affordable Housing of Lawrence County. A few grand jury participants wanted to know about the retired New Castle school administrator.
“I was there for a good hour of questioning,” DeLorenzo said of his April 2008 testimony. “The only question (the jury) asked was about the character of Nick DeRosa.”
DeLorenzo served as board president in the final months of the nonprofit housing agency’s existence. While executive director of the Lawrence County housing authority, Robert Evanick helped found Affordable Housing in 2003.
He left the group in December 2005 after the board signed a $250,000 mortgage agreement with First Commonwealth Bank for the purchase of seven structures.
The agency defaulted on the loan in March 2006. DeRosa owned or co-owned four of the seven properties.
A certified public accountant, DeLorenzo provided the government with the documentation and insight that led to charges being filed against DeRosa and four other parties.
DeRosa pleaded guilty Oct. 28 to single felony counts of bank fraud, mail fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. His sentencing is scheduled for March 1.
IMAGE
The unfolding of the Affordable Housing scandal magnified the differences between DeRosa’s public image and private life.
He was elected to city council, served two terms on the Slippery Rock University Council of Trustees and sat on the Lawrence County Planning Commission board.
DeRosa’s community service included work with the American Heart Association, the American Cancer Society and Easter Seals. He also was former president of the National Association of Wolves, an Italian service organization.
However, DeRosa is best known for his association with the New Castle Area School District. A 1963 Ne-Ca-Hi graduate, he was hired as an elementary teacher. DeRosa was promoted to principal and became assistant superintendent in 1989.
Although never naming him, a 2003 state Auditor General’s report detailed problems involving the educator. The findings outlined gambling activities that permitted DeRosa to receive free hotel rooms for three school board members attending a conference in 2002; a failure to disclose financial interests; the purchase of boxed lunches from the district for a business DeRosa owned; and his conduct regarding travel while representing the school system.
The audit led the school board to hire attorney Richard A. Harper in March 2004 to conduct an independent review.
“The Harper Report focuses on one thing and one thing only — the assistant superintendent (Nicholas DeRosa),” district solicitor Charles Sapienza said in a June 24, 2006, interview.
TARGET
Likewise, federal investigators made him the target of its mortgage fraud probe.
DeRosa originally pleaded not guilty to the charges. Prior to the change, defense attorney Efrem Grail filed objections to portions of the government’s evidence.
One of the complaints dealt with DeRosa’s role as a landlord.
Government investigators talked to former tenants, one of which referred to him as a “slumlord.” New Castle code enforcement had condemned a Wallace Avenue property that DeRosa co-owned five days after Castle Realty inspected it for an appraisal. Rats were reportedly living in the properties, and truckloads of trash were removed.
Federal prosecutors also were prepared to tie DeRosa to the theft of quarters from housing authority laundry machines, kickbacks involving a housing authority grass-cutting contract and money he and former county treasurer Gary Felasco reportedly collected from a bingo hall operator.
In court paperwork, Grail called the evidence improper and said that it tainted “Mr. DeRosa’s character in the eyes of the jury, to show he has a propensity to do wrong, to paint him as a bad person.”
DeRosa faces three to four years in prison, probation, restitution, forfeiture of assets and fines. He remains free on $10,000 unsecured bond.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)